Dogs absolutely loved these! And it's a great way to get them coconut oil. It makes their coat so nice and soft. There was a lot of controversy in the websites reviews about cinnamon and whether it was harmful for dogs or not. I left the cinnamon out just in case and added pureed banana instead. I'll do my own research about the cinnamon and depending on what I find I may try with the cinnamon next time. Also I let the mixture cool slightly then (very quickly) managed to roll them into balls. I ordered a silicone tray for next time.