This was very good, I have a few adjustments I would like to try next time. The juice was thin, I think next time I will either substitute the broth for a gravy or add flour to make a thicker sauce. I am going to also add peas , I think it would be a nice flavor addition. The garlic mashed potatoes we amazing and have already shared this recipe with a friend. This flavor combination made this one of the best Sheppards Pies I have ever eaten.