So good! My fresh dill had gone bad, so I just used a ton of dry dill. I would use only 1/2 cup of mayo next time. It's a little too much as is. I also only used maybe 1 tbsp of the onion. Just a couple of small wedges chopped up. I think bacon and/or cayenne would be good additions. I would not want more than that! One kid loved it, the other tolerated it.