By Kurt Stoll
MOM’s CHRISTMAS BUTTER COOKIE RECIPE (Updated)
16 steps
Prep:1hCook:13min
Updated at: Tue, 24 Dec 2024 16:48:36 GMT
Nutrition balance score
Unbalanced
Glycemic Index
69
High
Glycemic Load
30
High
Nutrition per serving
Calories320.4 kcal (16%)
Total Fat15.6 g (22%)
Carbs43.7 g (17%)
Sugars31.4 g (35%)
Protein2.6 g (5%)
Sodium119.4 mg (6%)
Fiber0.4 g (2%)
% Daily Values based on a 2,000 calorie diet
Ingredients
20 servings
COOKIES
COOKIE ICING
Instructions
THE NIGHT BEFORE
Step 1
Set Butter out on Kitchen Counter to warm up to room temperature
THE DAY OF - MIX COOKIE BATTER
Step 2
PRE-HEAT OVEN TO 35O DEGREES
Step 3
IN A MIXING BOWL, CREAM THE BUTTER

Step 4
GRADUALLY ADD SUGAR AND BEAT UNTIL LIGHT AND FLUFFY

Step 5
BEAT IN EGG AND VANILLA EXTRACT


Step 6
GRADUALLY BLEND IN FLOUR.

Step 7
CHILL DOUGH FOR EASE IN HANDLING (AT LEAST 2 HOURS)
Step 8
ROLL OUT DOUGH ON LIGHTLY FLOURED SURFACE TO ¼” THICKNESS.
Step 9
CUT INTO DESIRED SHAPES WITH FLOURED ASSORTED COOKIE CUTTERS. PLACE ON BAKING SHEET. (Try putting baking sheet back into fridge for 30 minutes before putting in oven)
Step 10
BAKE 13 MINUTES.
Step 11
REMOVE IMMEDIATELY TO WIRE RACK TO COOL.
MAKE COOKIE ICING:
Step 12
SET BUTTER OUT ON COUNTER THE NIGHT BEFORE TO MAKE SURE IT IS AT ROOM TEMPERATURE FOR MIXING.
Step 13
IN A MIXING BOWL, COMBINE: 1 LB. POWDERED SUGAR, DASH OF SALT, ½ CUP CANNED CREAM (SWEETENED CONDENSED MILK), 1 TEASPOON VANILLA, 1/3 CUP (2/3 STICK SOFT BUTTER).





Step 14
BEAT WITH ELECTRIC MIXER UNTIL SMOOTH AND CREAMY. (SCRAPE BOWL OFTEN).
Step 15
ADD FOOD COLORING (AS NECESSARY) TO ACHIEVE DESIRED ICING COLOR
Step 16
IF TOO STIFF TO SPREAD EASILY, ADD A FEW DROPS OF MILK.
Notes
1 liked
0 disliked
Delicious
Go-to
Kid-friendly
Sweet