How To Make The Best Potato Salad Recipe

I made it without egg and it was really good the family liked it.

Great recipe, was delicious. It tasted even better the next day.

3/4 tablespoon of celery seed, and I used bread and butter pickles and sweet relish. I also added chopped bacon.

Really good. Might put my own spin on it next time I make it.

Chopped dill pickles and added a splash of pickle juice in place of relish. Delicious! Could serve this warm too. Used fresh chives instead of sweet onion

We added a 1/4 cup of relish, it was amazing!

No photo — it’s all gone. We served this at a family picnic and reviews were mixed. People who liked it ate more than 1 serving. Some guest said it tasted different - maybe it was the dill?? I will make it again, but will definitely add more salt and pepper next time.

This was my second time making this recipe. I used soft boiled egg and made the yolk more of a part of the dressing. I think it helps the richness. I recommend a nice grind of pepper and more paprika as you go along.

I didn't have celery seed, just omitted

It was missing something.

Chop potatoes before cooking. Post cooking is challenging.

Made it exactly as recipe instructs. Creamy, delicious and feed a crowd. If you are making it just for your family cut everything in half and you’ll still have some leftover. Nice side for a cookout for 10 people.

Delicious and easy! I added a touch of olive brine I had on deck.

Everyone loved it, wanted recipe

I added a whole small jar of relish and eyeballed the seasoning to taste. I also peeled the potatoes before boiling and mashed them once they were soft (about 40 minutes) . So far everyone including me loves it. Tysm ❤️

Use this one, it’s the best!! It’s like deviled egg potato salad!

Love potato salad! I skipped the relish and used dill pickles and instead of apple vinegar a splash of that dill pickle juice! Mmmmmm

halve the celery seed and halve the mustard. use sweet pickle relish.