
By Nik Rup
🥔 Dairy-Free Cheesecake Factory-Inspired Mashed Potatoes
5 steps
Prep:15min
After a recent visit to the holy grail of portion sizes – yes, The Cheesecake Factory – I found myself completely smitten with their mashed potatoes. Creamy, indulgent, and with just the right hint of mystery, they were potato perfection.
But here’s the kicker: they don’t publish the recipe, nor do they list the full ingredients. Rude, right?
Nevertheless, with a bit of charm (and a lot of light pestering), I managed to wangle a dairy-free version directly from the restaurant. Combine that with years of my own mashed potato mastery and a borderline obsessive analysis of every copycat recipe on the internet, and voilà — we’ve cracked the code.
This version is entirely dairy-free, but don’t let that fool you — it still delivers the iconic tang from horseradish, the creamy, cheesy warmth (thanks to smoked vegan Gouda, you miracle of modern science), and a texture so silky it could negotiate its way out of a tribunal and get costs awarded.
And if you’re one of the dairy-tolerant masses, or just curious to compare, I’ve included a link to the original version below.
Link to original version:
https://s.samsungfood.com/jjSsv
Updated at: Fri, 18 Apr 2025 15:37:56 GMT
Nutrition balance score
Unbalanced
Glycemic Index
54
Low
Glycemic Load
18
Moderate
Nutrition per serving
Calories289.2 kcal (14%)
Total Fat16.3 g (23%)
Carbs33.1 g (13%)
Sugars2.5 g (3%)
Protein4.4 g (9%)
Sodium834.4 mg (42%)
Fiber3.3 g (12%)
% Daily Values based on a 2,000 calorie diet
Ingredients
4 servings

4 cupsred potatoes
skin-on or peeled, cubed

¼ cupdairy-free butter

1 teaspoonsalt
plus more to taste

2 tablespoonsprepared horseradish
check for dairy-free

1 cupdairy-free smoked Gouda-style cheese Vegan
or Applewood
Optional for creaminess:
Optional flavour additions
Optional Garnish - Either/Or:
Instructions
Step 1
Cube and boil potatoes in salted water until tender (15–20 mins).
*NB - leave skin on for texture.


Step 2
Drain and let steam dry briefly.

Step 3
Add dairy-free butter, horseradish, vegan cheese, and optional ingredients.
Step 4
Mash until creamy and smooth, adding plant milk if needed.
Step 5
Season to taste and garnish. Serve hot and feel proud.🙌