Shepherd's Pie

Probably wouldn't put the tomato paste for next time but overall 8/10 would try it again!

I made the mashed potatoes from scratch so it was a little thicker than the box kind but overall still really delicious and my picky nephew liked it too.

Way too runny. I would cut the broth down by at least half.

2nd time making this recipe and I think I’ve got it down! The original recipe is fine but this time around I used slightly less ground beef than the recipe called for, 3/4 of a large onion and I added 1 1/2 of Knorr chicken seasoning cubes. I’m sure I’ll be making this at least twice a month!

My family and I really liked it. I accidentally grabbed an 8oz jar of tomato sauce and not paste, but it turned out good.

Next time fry meat with garlic in addition to the onions

Subbed the tomato paste for A1 (plus some), only had 2 packages of powdered potatoes instead of the refrigerated ones, added some cheese and measured the spices by heart but fantastic! Another commenter said she put taters on the bottom and I will definitely do that next time. Easy, whole family went for seconds.

Used some short ribs instead of ground beef And put it under the broiler to brown

DO NOT ADD THE ITALIAN HERBS. Unless you just really like Italian herbs, it gives this a really weird and VERY herby flavor. I made it again and left out the Italian herbs and just added a pinch more salt and pepper and some seasoned salt. Delicious!

Added some Worcestershire Sauce and used frozen peas and (fresh)carrots instead of frozen veggies. Also made own mash and made it cheesy.

Maybe too much potato

It just didn't work out for me.

Added some more salt and a bit of Worcestershire Sauce for extra flavor

Delicious! 😋 We made our own mash potatoes by simply boiling the potatoes without skin, then mashing them and then added a pinch of garlic and pepper! We also added chopped up carrots instead of frozen veg, absolutely delish! 💯

Love it, added sugarsnaps of course! Carrots, onions, beef mince, lamb seasoning! And mash simple but tasty

Easy tasty and basic. Perfect for on a budget or beginner family chefs. A more experienced chef could easily take some license to make it an even better dish - I put cheese and panko crumbs on the top. I would have grilled it a little longer but the cat fell asleep on me after I put it in the oven so my boyfriend was in charge the finishing and plating. Pictured are the leftovers. I did use some crushed garlic. I like recipes that have fewer ingredients when we’re trying to use what’s in the cupboard.

Instead of using a separate baking dish, I used the oven-safe 12” pan I fried the hamburger in. This can be a one-pot meal :)

This is COTTAGE pie, shepherds pie is made with lamb

Added a little shredded cheese and put under the broiler to finish it off. Didn’t worry about getting the mashed potatoes all the way up to the sides. It was amazing, also added a little minced garlic to the ground beef and and onion mixture to beef up the garlic hints. Very good, definitely a go to easy meal to make in the 30 minute range.

Instead of regular potatoes, I added garlic baby red instant potatoes.

I didn’t have tomato paste but i had everything else and it turned out great! I added extra seasoning though.

I found this recipe to be kinda, meh. I think it's a good starting point, but you'll get the best results by experimenting a bit with the seasoning and bake times. Otherwise, it turns out a bit bland and mushy.

Don't waist your time. Just prepare the meat and mashed potatoes separately then put it together directly to the plate. I made my ground beef with honey bbq sauce instead of tomato paste, it was delicious.

I love this but I flipped it. I did potatoes on the bottom because it is WAY easier to spread AND the gravy soaks into it creating rich flavor. Love it!

First time ever eating this and will definitely will make it alot more

So simple and tasty 😋

We made our own mashed potatoes otherwise the same. It turned out great, the family loved it.

This recipe was easy and simple. I never had shepherds pie with tomato paste so it was different. We usually put cream corn in it so it felt like it was missing something.

I'd add a photo but internet is too poor lol. This was easy to make. Opted to make mashed potatoes from scratch, rather than some bag lol.

Yummy!! Moist and delicious!

It was good but it isn't shepherd's pie, it's cottage pie. Shepherd's pie has lamb in it, cottage pie has minced meat. There's a difference in the flavour.

Made with ground turkey and cauliflower potatoes.