Log in
Use App
…
Log in
Amish Baked Macaroni & Cheese
100%
0
By Jean Rucker

Amish Baked Macaroni & Cheese

10 steps
Prep:10minCook:1h
Inspired by Elias from Frugal Amish, YouTube
Updated at: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 19:41:31 GMT

Nutrition balance score

Unbalanced
Glycemic Index
49
Low
Glycemic Load
21
High

Nutrition per serving

Calories597.3 kcal (30%)
Total Fat34.2 g (49%)
Carbs43.9 g (17%)
Sugars11.8 g (13%)
Protein28.8 g (58%)
Sodium836.4 mg (42%)
Fiber1.4 g (5%)
% Daily Values based on a 2,000 calorie diet

Instructions

Step 1
Preheat oven to 350° F.
Step 2
Grease 8x8x2" glass or stoneware baking dish with butter or bacon drippings. Set on a baking tray for support and to catch spillage.
Step 3
Stir dry mustard, salt and pepper into cold milk.
Step 4
Add dry macaroni to greased baking dish and pour seasoned milk over macaroni in pan.
Step 5
Add 1.5 cups grated cheese to macaroni mixture in pan and lightly stir to level out mixture. Reserve remaining 1 cup cheese for the top.
Step 6
Cover tightly with foil and bake for 50 minutes in pre-heated oven. No peeking to check.
Step 7
After 50 minutes, remove pan from oven leaving oven on. And allow macaroni to rest still covered with foil for 10 minutes. Again, no peeking.
Step 8
Now remove foil and carefully stir to combine any remaining pockets of cheese and scatter reserved grated cheese on top.
Step 9
Return to heated oven for an additional 10 minutes until cheese is melted and edges are lightly brown.

Leftovers Suggestion

Step 10
Any leftovers can be placed in fridge overnight and cut into squares or shaped into patties, dipped in beaten egg and cracker crumbs and fried until crispy on outside and creamy inside.

Notes

0 liked
1 disliked
There are no notes yet. Be the first to share your experience!